Do you suffer from chronic pain or muscle tension? Perhaps you work a job that leaves you feeling wound up and stressed out at the end of the day. Maybe you suffer from any one of a number of musculature or autoimmune disorders that can wreak havoc on the body causing pain, knotted tendons, headaches, and general feelings of uneasiness.
You are not alone. Back and muscle pain make up the second most common reason for medical visits worldwide. With so many people struggling to find comfort in their homes, automobiles, and offices, it is no surprise that the massage chair industry especially massage chair pad has become one of the most competitive on the market with thousands of manufacturers and millions of products distributed worldwide.
About Massage Chair Pad
Since the first product of its kind was introduced into the market in the 1980s, there has been a steady increase in massage chair pad products. The market has expanded to offer a variety of products boasting different massage techniques and quality. They can assist in easing chronic pain disorders like arthritis and fibromyalgia, alleviate stress, and relax the body.
Best Massage Chair Pad Reviews
Below, we at Comfy Massage Chair will review three of the best massage chair pads on the market to determine the overall quality of each and determine the best of the three options. All 3 options are all available for purchase at a number of online retailers, including Amazon and are highly-recommended by chiropractors and physicians alike. The 3 best massage chair pads are:
- Viktor Jurgen Massage Seat
- Price Range:
- Adaptor: Car & Home
- Swedish massage only
- Portable but Noisy
- Mid-range massage strength
- HoMedics Quad Shiatsu Massage Seat
- Price Range:
- Adaptor: 110v only
- Swedish & Shiatsu massage
- Not portable but Quiet
- Strong massage strength
- FiveStar Massage Seat
- Price Range:
- Adaptor: Car & Home
- Swedish massage only
- Portable and Quiet
- Adjustable massage strength
So which is the best for you? Let’s take a look.
Viktor Jurgen 6-Motor Vibration Massage Seat Cushion with Heat
This model has the lowest retail price of the three on Amazon and boasts a variety of unique features.
Feature #1: Offers Magnetism Therapy
For one, it is the only cushion of the three that offers magnetism therapy. Magnetism therapy is an alternative medical practice that uses static electric waves to alleviate pain throughout the body. Many people have experienced wonderful results from magnetism therapy and it is one of the features that makes this product so appealing.
Feature #2: Equipped with Timer
It also comes equipped with a 30-minute timer control to prevent overheating. If you fall asleep on the seat or walk away and forget that it is running, you don’t have to worry about motors burning up or a house fire, because the machine knows to shut itself off.
Feature #3: Lightweight & Portable
It also markets itself as lightweight and portable, which opens it up for use anywhere you would like and, since it boasts both plug-in adapters for the car and home, it can become a full-time accessory.
Real Users Feedback
When perusing customer reviews for the Viktor Jurgen model, many customers are pleased with the strength of the massage that this cushion offers. It does not provide a soft, barely noticeable vibration like many other budget models. Instead, the motors of this cushion work hard to massage deep into the body tissue. It does only offer a Swedish massage without a Shiatsu option, but most of the customers who reviewed the product felt that the massage was strong enough to work effectively anyway.
The heating feature, however, did not receive as many praises. A lot of customers felt that the heat was not warm enough. Some even went as far as to say that the heat was barely noticeable at all.
The appearance of the cushion garnered praise, however. It appears to be an attractive and comfortable seat with an easy-to-use handheld remote. The remote does not come equipped with back lighting, which some customers complained about. Other customers, however, said that the remote was easy enough to use and memorize that a lighting feature was not necessary. Many customers were also thrilled with the body-coverage of the cushion’s lengthy design.
If there was one complaint about this model that stood out above all others, it was regarding the noisiness of the cushion motors. Some customers said that they were embarrassed to take the cushion to work with them because of the sound. Another said that he couldn’t use the cushion at his desk at home because the buzzing broke his concentration.
Homedics Quad Shiatsu Massage Cushion with Heat
This massage chair pad comes in with the heaviest price tag of the three. The price tag promises all the bells and whistles you’d hope for in a massage chair pad and so does the advertising.
Feature #1: Specialized Motors
This cushion offers a variety of different massage techniques with specialized motors that knead, roll, and vibrate in percussion for a better chance at a deep tissue massage. The massages, themselves, can be customized by zones or you can select a full-body massage just as easily.
Feature #2: Extended Warranties
Homedics is also known for offering great extended warranties with full replacements possible on defective products.
At first glance, the pricier Homedics model seems to be the best option, but how do the promises measure up to the actual product, itself?
In contrast to the Viktor Jurgen model, the Homedics model is less portable. It can’t be taken in the car because it only runs on a 110v adapter. The size of the cushion, also, makes it impossible to use it in all chairs.
Real Users Feedback
Amazon customer reviews for this model are mostly positive, but there are deviations in opinion about quality and comfort. Many customers seem to be disappointed by the padding system over the roller motors. Some customers even go as far as to say the roller massage was painful. One customer even stated in her review that it is impossible for her to use the cushion without placing a folded towel or blanket between her body and the cushion and that she experienced bruises the first time she used the device.
It should be remembered, though, that all body and muscle types are different and what is uncomfortable for one person may feel just fine for others. Another reviewer stated that the massage was everything he had hoped it would be and tough-to-reach knots in his back were cured after the first use. Other reviewers complained that the heat of the device ran too hot, a stark contrast to the complaints of poor heating capabilities in the Viktor Jurgen model.
One reviewer claimed to have suffered burns from the Homedics cushion. This leads a potential consumer to believe that perhaps the issue is not actually in the padding, after all, but in the lack of temperature choices and impact control.
Other reviewers complained that the quality of the fabric was poor and wore out after only a few uses. Some even stated that the adapter quit working, implying that there may be manufacturing issues with this product that are not reflected in the high price tag.
Five Star FS8812 10-Motor Massage Seat Cushion with heat
This model falls well below the price range of the Homedics model and competes nicely alongside our earlier Viktor Jurgen model.
Feature #1: 10 Motors and Heat
Right away, it is easy to tell that there are a lot of options involved in using this cushion. The name of the product, itself, boasts ten motors and heat, which makes for an attractive offer at such a low price. The motors allow a choice of intensity. This is a great option for customers, like the one who was so unhappy with the Homedics option, who may be more sensitive to higher vibrations and heat. Like the Homedics model, the Five Star also offers zone selection so you can custom-create your perfect massage. At its strongest, consumers rate the massage “very strong” and the heat at an adequate temperature.
Feature #2: Only Swedish Massage
Unfortunately, the only massage type offered is a Swedish massage, but most consumers seemed to feel that this was an adequate feature in itself and don’t seem to miss the added appeal of additional massage types.
Real Users Feedback
Of all three of the models, the Five Star seems to have acquired the most overwhelmingly positive reviews from its consumers. Like the Viktor Jurgen, many customers were carried away by the convenience and added assurance provided by the safety shut off mechanism. Again, the handheld control was also a big hit, only this time the proper back lighting was provided. This undoubtedly helps in winning over many of the customers who were turned away by a lack of back lighting option on the Viktor Jurgen.
The power source can be used in either house or home, which is an inviting attribute for those who need the extra help on long car rides. Another bonus is that the motors run much quieter than the Viktor Jurgen model making this a suitable choice for office dwellers.
Reviews weren’t all great, however. Many consumers stated that they had to contact customer service in regards to power supply issues and faulty motors. The good news is that, overall, these consumers seemed satisfied with the customer service experiences they received from the Five Star manufacturers and retailers and were generally pleased with their purchase when all was said and done.
The quality and comfort of the cushion also won praises in Amazon reviews, where many stated that it was one of the most comfortable massage chair cushions they’ve ever sat in.
Comparison between All 3 Models
So, which rated best overall? Let’s recap those five important factors we discussed at the beginning of the article to find out.
Factor #1: Affordability
The Homedics model was the least affordable, by far, boasting a hefty price tag of more than $150. The Five-Star model came in second at a more easy-to-reach price of under $100. The lowest cost award goes to the Viktor Jurgen model at slightly below $50.
Factor #2: Power-Supply
The clear loser in this situation is, again, the Homedics model with its limited portability. Because it can only be powered by a 110v adapter, it is impossible to use this massage chair cushion while driving. Both the Viktor Jurgen and Five Star models provide a car adapter as well as a home adapter, making them more attractive options for anyone who may need their cushion during transportation. In this case, the Viktor Jurgen wins out because of the risk of power-source defects associated with the Five Star model.
Factor #3: Massage-type
All three options offer a Swedish massage, but only the Homedics model provides a Shiatsu option, as well. The roller-ball, percussion, and kneading options are no doubt the reason for that high price tag, however with limited control over the massage intensity, the cushion can be more painful than helpful. The magnetism therapy associated with the Viktor Jurgen model could be an attractive draw, although many massage therapists would discount the credibility of magnets in massage effectiveness. The Viktor Jurgen, also, had complaints of being too strong for some consumers where the Five Star had more control options, but was still limited to only a vibrating massage. The winner in this category is the Homedics model, simply because of the added feature of a variety of massage types, despite the intensity issues associated with the cushion.
Factor #4: Overall Comfort
All three models had varying reviews regarding comfort. The Viktor Jurgen model was lightweight and easily portable for use in the home, car, or office. Many consumers, though, were put off by the noisiness of the motors and felt too embarrassed to use the product in a work-setting. Additionally, it was hard to use at night due to the lack of a back lighting feature on the remote.
The Homedics model seemed to have the most complaints about comfort. Some consumers even complained that they had been burned and bruised by the use of the cushion. It is also less portable due to the power-source limitations making it an unlikely choice for people on the go. Combine that with the inability of this cushion to fit in all chair types and it comes in dead last in the comfort comparison.
The Five Star model boasts the same portability as the Viktor Jurgen model, but has a quieter motor making it a more appealing choice for individuals who work in an office setting. The overall comfort of the padding and cushioning of the chair seems to be acceptable based on a lack of complaints stating otherwise.
As far as overall comfort goes, it would seem the Five Star wins based on its portable, safety-conscious, and discrete design.
Factor #5: Strength
The final factor to consider is strength, which proved to be a landslide victory for one of our models, in particular.
The Viktor Jurgen boasted a suitable mid-range massage strength, but fell short when it came to heat. Many consumers were upset about the low temperature provided by the cushion’s heat setting, some even stating that it did not feel like any heat was coming through the padding at all.
The Homedics model had complaints of being too strong in both heat and massage settings. Some consumers complained of being bruised or burned by the cushion while others stated that the cushion worked wonderfully. A lack of control options ultimately killed the viability of the Homedics option for those who have sensitivities to heat or bruise easily.
The Five Star cushion won overall, again, for its heat and massage-strength controls. Because the seat allows choices, it is easy for everyone to pick the setting that best suits their body-type and situation. This ensures a massage that is not only strong enough, but a seat that is also warm enough without risk of injury or discomfort.